Big chains get better prices than you. Everybody knows that. What the FTC says the country’s largest wine and spirits distributor did is different: it allegedly gave the chains discounts small stores were never even told about, and charged independents more for the same bottle a few blocks away.
On Oct. 2, the FTC settled that fight with Southern Glazer’s Wine and Spirits. If you buy anything you resell, from wine to packaging to parts, the reason it matters is hiding in a 1936 law most owners have never heard of.
Wait, Isn’t a Bulk Discount Just Normal?
Yes, and it’s legal. Under the Robinson-Patman Act, a supplier can charge a big buyer less when selling to that buyer actually costs less: one giant delivery instead of 40 small ones, less paperwork, fewer trucks.
The FTC’s case, filed in December 2024, said Southern Glazer’s went past that. It alleged the distributor gave chains like Total Wine (the big-box liquor superstore), Costco and Kroger discounts and rebates that went beyond any real cost savings. And it said small stores often weren’t told about the deals at all, even when they could have qualified.
Be our guestYour next big opportunity could be in a room you're not in.Meet CEOs, founders and owners at a reception in your city or online. Your first event is on us.Request my guest seat →
That’s the part that should make you sit up. Not “they got a better price.” More like “there was a better price, and nobody told you it existed.”
What It Looks Like From Behind the Counter
Lou Wildeman owns one liquor store, SoBro Spirits in Indianapolis. To get anywhere near chain pricing, he buys through a co-op of 35 stores, which costs his shop about $29,109 a year, according to a report by Noël Burgess on Yahoo Creators. Wildeman told Indiana regulators that back in 1978, deal thresholds started at 10 or 15 cases. Now some run 2,000 to 5,000 cases.
He called the co-op a “necessary evil.” His summary of the whole thing: “All we do is try to compete.”
How the Settlement Works
An independent monitor will watch Southern Glazer’s for six years in 26 states. If a nearby independent pays a lot more than one of the five biggest chains for the same product, and the overcharge tops $5,000 in a year, Southern Glazer’s pays that store 1.5 times the difference. Refuse to pay, lose in court, and it’s double.
Southern Glazer’s says it did nothing wrong, settled without admitting it, and doesn’t expect “material changes to our business or pricing practices.” Back in 2024, it said it makes “all discount levels available to all eligible retailers.” FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson, who voted against filing the case, said most price differences can be justified by cost, and the company “pays only where a monitor finds that an independent retailer actually paid more than a competing chain.”
Before Your Next Meeting
You may never sell a bottle of wine. But if a supplier sets your price, this is your story too. What would you do?
- Do you actually know every deal your supplier offers? The FTC alleged small stores weren’t told about discounts they could have used. On your next order, ask your rep to send every discount, rebate and promo tier in writing, along with what it takes to qualify.
- A bigger customer gets a better price. Is it the volume, or something else? A price gap is legal when it reflects real savings, and Southern Glazer’s says its pricing always did. Ask your supplier what the gap is based on, and decide what answer would send you shopping for another supplier.
- You can’t hit the volume alone. Who could you buy with? Wildeman pays about $29,000 a year to buy with 34 other stores, and calls it a “necessary evil.” Find out whether a buying group or a few owners in your space could pool orders to reach the next price tier.
Five Questions to Ask Before You Hire an Experiential Marketing AgencyBy Sheila Rondeau
The CEO Who Built a Company Around Language Just Wrote the Book That Explains Why Language Is the Most Important Technology in Human HistoryBy Michael Beas
C-Suite Radio · Crunching Your Growth – Growth ClassRegulated Wellness Ecommerce: Growing a THC-Free Brand with Bobby Riganati Meet the founders, CEOs and operators behind stories like this one. Next reception: Dallas Executive Reception, Wed, Nov 18.
Attend as a guestMembership: $100/mo →



































