A company asked its top payroll employee about $260,000 that had gone missing. She said it was a software issue. She didn’t show up the next day. Now the company says the real number is more than $8.2 million, paid out over eight years to workers who didn’t exist.
The company is nextSource, a New York firm founded in 1998 that handles staffing administration and payroll for large corporate clients. Yes, a payroll company. If a business whose whole job is getting payroll right says this happened inside its own walls, it’s worth five minutes of yours.
What the Lawsuit Says Happened
On Oct. 12, an accounting executive at nextSource noticed more than $260,000 in payments from the previous two months had gone to a Tennessee bank account with no link to any known worker or client.
When the company asked about it, the employee, a woman from Mt. Juliet, Tenn., reportedly blamed a software issue. The next day she didn’t come to work, and files in the company’s system were allegedly altered or deleted. She later admitted to the owner that she was responsible for the recent payments, promised to repay them, and sent back $267,792.
Be our guestYour next big opportunity could be in a room you're not in.Meet CEOs, founders and owners at a reception in your city or online. Your first event is on us.Request my guest seat →
Then the company kept digging. Its lawsuit, filed Oct. 20 in Davidson County Chancery Court in Nashville, alleges she created fake worker profiles in the payroll system and moved more than $8.2 million to her own account over eight years. The company also says others may have been involved.
A judge froze the bank account, blocked any sale of her real estate and barred destroying evidence, with a hearing set for Nov. 3. She told WKRN News 2 she has “no comment on the case at this time.” No criminal charges have been reported, and the company’s claims have not been proven in court.
Wait, How Does Nobody Notice $8.2 Million?
Spread over eight years, it’s roughly $1 million a year, tucked inside a payroll big enough to serve major corporate clients. A fake worker doesn’t look fake in the system. It’s a name, a bank account and a paycheck that shows up every cycle like everyone else’s.
The numbers on this kind of fraud aren’t comforting. In the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners’ 2024 global study, payroll schemes ran a median of 18 months before anyone caught them. The most common way any fraud got caught was a tip from someone (43% of cases), not software. And at businesses with fewer than 100 employees, only 14% did formal fraud risk assessments, compared with 56% of larger organizations.
One more stat worth sitting with: losses grew with tenure. Fraud by people who’d been there more than 10 years had a median loss of $250,000. The person you trust most is usually the person with the most access.
Before Your Next Meeting
Most owners will never face an $8 million problem. Almost all of them have one person who knows the money better than they do. What would you do?
- Your bookkeeper has run payroll alone for years and never takes a vacation. Do you change anything? The alleged scheme here ran through one top payroll person for eight years. Who besides that person sees who gets paid, and when did someone last match every name on payroll to a real human?
- You spot a payment you can’t explain, and the answer is “software glitch.” Accept it, dig quietly, or call a lawyer? In this case, the company says files were altered or deleted the day after it asked. Decide what you’d lock down before you ask the question.
- Someone admits to a smaller amount and pays it back fast. Is that the end of it? The $267,792 came back before the company says it found the bigger number. Do you close the file, or go back through the years?
Chapter Six: What is Brand Training? Why Do You Need It?By Evan Hackel
The (HR) Problem Nobody Budgets ForBy Dina Simon
Trust Is the Currency of Nonprofit LeadershipBy Hugh Ballou
C-Suite Radio · The TriMetric Roadmap Podcast With Scott LandisWill a Bank Fund Your Next Big Opportunity?
Chairman's Corner · Jeffrey HayzlettYour Best Performer Might Be Your Biggest Problem. And It’s Contagious. Meet the founders, CEOs and operators behind stories like this one. Next reception: NYC Executive Reception, Tue, Nov 24.
Attend as a guestMembership: $100/mo →


































