Join Now
Thursday, November 19, 2026
HomeNewsLeadershipYour Best Performer Might Be Your Biggest Problem. And It’s Contagious.

Your Best Performer Might Be Your Biggest Problem. And It’s Contagious.

The quick take:

  • Harvard Business School researchers tracked nearly 60,000 front-line workers. The ones who got fired for things like harassment and fraud were often among the fastest workers on the team.
  • Their behavior spread. People on teams with more toxic coworkers were far more likely to get fired for misconduct themselves.
  • Why it matters now: it’s year-end review season, and the warning signs show up long before the damage does.

Want to know who is most likely to get fired for breaking the rules?

The person who swears the rules should never be broken.

That’s not my opinion. It’s one of the strangest findings from a Harvard Business School study of what the researchers called “toxic workers.” And it explains why so many owners keep the wrong person way too long.

Executives at a C-SUITE NETWORK receptionBe our guestYour next big opportunity could be in a room you're not in.Meet CEOs, founders and owners at a reception in your city or online. Your first event is on us.Request my guest seat →

What they actually studied

Dylan Minor of Harvard Business School and Michael Housman, an analytics executive at a hiring-software company, looked at nearly 60,000 front-line workers at 11 companies over three years. These were sales and customer service jobs in retail, financial services and health care.

They defined “toxic” narrowly. Not annoying. Not grumpy. Toxic meant fired for serious misconduct: harassment, violence, fraud, falsifying documents. That was about 1 in 20 workers.

Then they looked at what those people were like before they blew up.

They were faster. They weren’t better.

Here’s the trap. The toxic workers got their work done faster than average, the paper found. But the quality of their work wasn’t any better.

That’s how they hide. On the scoreboard, they look like your stars. Speed is easy to see. What they’re doing to the people around them isn’t.

Every owner knows this person. Hits the number. Customers love them. Half the team would rather eat glass than sit in a meeting with them. And you look the other way, because the numbers are the numbers.

Then it spreads

This is the part that should scare you.

The researchers measured how many toxic coworkers each person had around them. The more toxic people on a team, the more likely everyone else was to end up fired for misconduct too. In one of their models, a modest increase in exposure nearly doubled the odds.

Bad behavior isn’t just tolerated on those teams. It’s learned.

Minor’s advice for managers when a toxic worker has been on a team for a while: “They’ve been potentially contaminated. Put the yellow suit on.”

Now the math, in plain English

The study put a price on two kinds of hires in these jobs.

A superstar, someone in the top 1% for productivity, was worth at most about $5,303 a year. That sounds small because these are hourly jobs, and the researchers measured it as what you’d pay to hire extra people to match that output.

A toxic worker cost at least $12,489. That number is only the cost of replacing the good coworkers who quit because of them. It doesn’t count lawsuits, fines or the hit to everyone else’s morale.

So in the same jobs, one toxic hire cost about 2.4 times what the very best hire brought in. Your dollar amounts will be bigger. The lesson isn’t different.

Brand card: One toxic hire costs more than twice (2.4 times) what your best hire makes you, and the behavior spreads
Source: Housman and Minor, “Toxic Workers,” Harvard Business School.

The three warning signs

The most useful part of the study is what predicted toxic behavior before anyone got hired.

1. Overconfidence. Applicants rated their own skills, like typing speed, before they were tested. The ones who overrated themselves were more likely to turn toxic. “If you’re overconfident, you think you’re less likely to be caught,” Minor said.

2. Selfishness. People who showed little concern for others were more likely to steal and bully.

3. Claiming the rules should never be broken. The applicants who insisted on it were the ones more likely to get fired for breaking them. “To say the rules should never be broken isn’t completely forthright and honest,” Minor said. Everybody bends a rule sometime. The people who say they never do aren’t being straight with you.

Tension is good. Toxic isn’t.

I’ve always said a leader’s job is to create tension. Push people from the center of the stage to the edge. Healthy debate makes a business better.

But tension is about ideas. Toxic is about people. One makes the team sharper. The other makes the team smaller.

I want big dogs on my team. But a big dog who bites everybody in the yard isn’t helping you win. And mood beats culture every day. One person can set the mood for an entire office, and now we know it’s contagious.

Your people know it, too. In a 2026 iHire survey, 47.6% of U.S. workers said they have quit a job because of a toxic workplace, and 79.1% of those who lived through it blamed leadership, according to the report. They don’t blame the jerk. They blame the boss who kept the jerk.

Don’t get comfortable because nobody is quitting right now. Quit rates are near historic lows. Your good people may just be waiting.

What to do about it

1. Score how, not just how much. If reviews and bonuses only count the number, you are paying people to get it any way they can.

2. Test for it before you hire. Ask candidates to rate their own skills, then test them. Ask, “Is it ever OK to break a rule?” The honest answer is “Yes, sometimes, and here’s when.” Watch out for the person who says never.

3. Watch the people next to them. It spreads. Look at who has started acting like your problem person, and who has gone quiet.

4. Say it to their face, once. I believe in radical transparency and in second chances. Name the specific behavior, set a short deadline and real consequences, and keep your word.

5. If it doesn’t change, move fast. Every month you wait, it spreads to someone else.

A superstar who breaks your team isn’t a superstar. They’re a very expensive vacancy.

Before Your Next Meeting

  • Who on our team hits the number but leaves damage behind, and what is it really costing us?
  • Has anyone started acting like them, or gone quiet around them?
  • Do our reviews and bonuses reward how people work, or only what they close?
Jeffrey Hayzlett
Jeffrey Hayzletthttp://hayzlett.com/
Jeffrey Hayzlett is a primetime television host of C-Suite with Jeffrey Hayzlett and Executive Perspectives on C-Suite TV, and business podcast host of All Business with Jeffrey Hayzlett on C-Suite Radio. He is a global business celebrity, speaker, best-selling author, and Chairman and CEO of C-Suite Network, home of the world’s most trusted network of C-Suite leaders. Hayzlett is a well-traveled public speaker, former Fortune 100 CMO, and author of four best-selling business books: Think Big, Act Bigger: The Rewards of Being Relentless, Running the Gauntlet, The Mirror Test and The Hero Factor: How Great Leaders Transform Organizations and Create Winning Cultures. Hayzlett is one of the most compelling figures in business today and an inductee into the National Speakers Association’s Speaker Hall of Fame. As a leading business expert, Hayzlett is frequently cited in Forbes, SUCCESS, Mashable, Marketing Week and Chief Executive, among many others. He shares his executive insight and commentary on television networks like Bloomberg, MSNBC, Fox Business, and C-Suite TV. Hayzlett is a former Bloomberg contributing editor and primetime host, and has appeared as a guest celebrity judge on NBC’s Celebrity Apprentice with Donald Trump for three seasons. He is a turnaround architect of the highest order, a maverick marketer and c-suite executive who delivers scalable campaigns, embraces traditional modes of customer engagement, and possesses a remarkable cachet of mentorship, corporate governance, and brand building.
RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

C-Suite TV · From the NYSETrust Is the Strategy: Jeanniey Walden on AI, Relatability, and Marketing That Moves the Needle25 min · Watch now
Members talking at a C-Suite Network reception
Before C-Suite, I was building in isolation. Now I'm surrounded by executives who push me forward.
Dan E. Silberberg · Founder & CEO, Entelechy Join for $100/moBook a 15-minute call Up to 600 events a year with founders and CEOs running real companies.
WatchC-Suite TV · Filmed at the NYSE
Watch now
Trust Is the Strategy: Jeanniey Walden on AI, Relatability, and Marketing That Moves the Needle25 min · Watch now AI Is Coming for More Than Jobs: The Fight to Rehumanize the Future with Denis JacquetAI Is Leveling the Playing Field: How Small Businesses Can Compete and Win with Robin AlexThe Future of Financial Advice is More Human, Not Less with CJ Davidson All episodes on C-Suite TV →
Have something worth saying?
Get seen. Get heard.

Get listed as an expert, publish your articles, launch or bring over your podcast, or put your show on C-Suite TV: Roku, Apple TV, Fire TV and every major podcast app, in front of senior business leaders.

Get seen & heardSee how it works
Come as a guest
See the room before you join.

Up to 600 events a year, and every one is open to guests except council meetings. Most people start at a city reception, and your first one is on us. Members get free entry to all of them.

Request my guest seatMembership: $100/mo
→Member account & business toolsThe tools included with membership: a CRM for your contacts, email marketing, calendar booking and landing pages ✎Contributor PortalPublishing and show resources for contributors, plus shared files Not a member yet? See membership →
Get visibility
Make the market know your name.

Publish your articles on C-Suite Network, get your advisor listing and host your own show on C-Suite Radio and TV.

Get seen & heard$250/mo total, including membership